Why didn’t you take shared parental leave this year?

Did you take any shared parental leave this year? If not, why not?

Perhaps it’s because your employer doesn’t enhance shared parental pay. Perhaps your wife or partner didn’t want to give up her maternity leave. Perhaps you were concerned about the impact it might have on your career. Or perhaps you’re not eligible or have never even heard of it.

Or perhaps it’s just because you haven’t had a child in the last year.

That’s right: the much-quoted “only 1% of dads chose to take shared parental leave” headline doing the rounds over the last week is not quite what it seems. The figure, from a report by My Family Care, a consultancy, refers to all men, not just those who have had a child in the last year.

When the context of the statistic is considered, the uptake of SPL starts to look a bit more encouraging. If 1% of all men, whether they are eligible dads or not, took some shared parental leave in the last year, then that ought to be a fairly large number of people. As Tim Harford says in the Radio 4 More or Less episode on this subject, even if every eligible father in the UK had taken some shared parental leave, the statistic would still only be around 5%!

It’s a shame because this stat and the widespread misreporting of it could potentially discourage families from taking shared parental leave in reluctance to do something that appears to be highly unusual. It’s a shame that the media outlets who reported on this last week failed to pick up on this important bit of context. I’m not pointing fingers: I did a number of TV and radio interviews myself last week and also assumed the statistic referred to eligible fathers only. I have learned my lesson from that.

There is some room for optimism though. A different survey, conducted by recruiters Totaljobs, suggested that many people (whether parents or not) understand the benefits of sharing leave and would be keen to make use of SPL in the future. The My Family Care survey found similar results. Both surveys suggest that British families are open to the idea of sharing leave, and that the old-fashioned view that childcare is just for women is not so deeply entrenched as some had feared.

With fairer pay and some encouragement many more dads might still take on some of the childcare burden in the future.

Advertisements

2 comments

  1. Jonathan

    The methods used to arrive at the 1% figure sound truly ridiculous, and potentially driven by a sensationalist agenda. I’m really glad to see you unpicking these figures. Whilst the share parental leave scheme is in may ways a step in the right direction, it doesn’t take the UK to anything like as good a system as in Scandinavian countries.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Dad on Leave

      I’m glad you liked it and thanks for commenting.

      In fairness to the researchers, the report was clear that the figure referred to all men and not just eligible dads. The media didn’t pick up on that nuance until it was pointed out a day or two later though.

      The data comes from HR departments who it seems are not always aware of how many people in their organisations are actually eligible for SPL. But without that information it’s a bit of a meaningless stat!

      I completely agree that SPL is a step in the right direction, but that there is a long way to go to make it a really good system. It’s tricky to please everyone: dads want more leave, mums don’t want to lose their maternity leave, business don’t want lengthier absences (especially if they have to pay for them). But if we could get something like the Scandinavian model I feel it would bring a whole lot more benefit to mums, dads, kids and employers than SPL does in its current form. I hope this is the start of incremental change.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s